Schedule a Consultation (401) 854-7794

Not Guilty RI

Weighing the Options: When Is a Plea Offer a Good Deal in a Criminal Case?

Posted by Kara Hoopis Manosh | Sep 18, 2023 | 0 Comments

Facing criminal charges is a daunting experience, and one critical decision defendants often face is whether to accept a plea offer or proceed to trial. Choosing between the two requires careful consideration of various factors. We'll explore the key elements that go into determining whether a plea offer is a good deal and when it might be advantageous to accept it, as opposed to risking a trial.

1. Strength of the Evidence:

One of the primary factors in assessing a plea offer is the strength of the evidence against the defendant. If the evidence is overwhelmingly against them, it may be challenging to secure an acquittal at trial. In such cases, a favorable plea offer might be a more attractive option.

2. Potential Sentencing:

Understanding the potential sentencing consequences is crucial. A good plea offer often includes a reduced sentence compared to what the defendant might face if convicted at trial. Consider the severity of the charges and the potential penalties associated with a conviction.

3. Legal Counsel:

Having experienced legal representation can significantly impact the decision-making process. A skilled attorney can evaluate the case, assess the strengths and weaknesses, and provide invaluable advice on whether to accept a plea offer or proceed to trial.  It can help to develop the strategy for a defense at trial, and then assess the likelihood of success - the pros and cons.  Your attorney should share their experience with similar cases in order to help you evaluate your options. 

4. Collateral Consequences:

Consider any collateral consequences that may result from a conviction, such as loss of employment, immigration status implications, or the impact on professional licenses. These factors can influence the attractiveness of a plea offer.

5. Trial Risks:

Trials involve inherent risks, including the uncertainty of a jury's verdict. Defendants should weigh the potential risks of going to trial, including the possibility of a harsher sentence if convicted, versus a complete exoneration if the jury says "not guilty."  Sometimes the prosecutor makes this decision easier by making an offer that is practically the maximum sentence you could receive after trial! 

6. Negotiation Leverage:

Assess the strength of your negotiation leverage. If the prosecution's case has weaknesses, or if there are legal issues that could be raised at trial, you may have better bargaining power to secure a favorable plea deal.  

7. Timing and Court Backlog:

Consider the timing of your case and the backlog in the court system. A plea offer might be more appealing if it allows for a quicker resolution and avoids a prolonged trial process. Will the case be off your record before you will even get a trial date? Sometimes, that plays an important role in your decision about how to proceed. 

8. Defendant's Prior Record:

The defendant's criminal history and prior convictions can impact the prosecution's willingness to offer a plea deal. A clean record may lead to more favorable plea terms.  Conversely, if the State has filed noticed of a habitual offender enhancement and is offering to withdraw the notice, it can be an important factor when considering a plea offer.

9. Personal Preferences:

Ultimately, the decision to accept a plea offer or go to trial is a deeply personal one. Consider your willingness to accept responsibility for the offense, your comfort with the uncertainty of a trial, and your desire to challenge the charges in court.  Nobody in the world can make this decision for you.  People you trust can certainly help you decide, but you must make the final decision based upon your own personal preferences and values. 

10. Consultation with Attorney:

The final decision should be made in consultation with your attorney. They can provide a clear understanding of the potential outcomes and help you make an informed choice that aligns with your best interests.

In conclusion, determining whether a plea offer is a good deal involves a comprehensive evaluation of multiple factors. It's a complex decision that should be made carefully and with the guidance of experienced legal counsel. Ultimately, the right choice depends on the unique circumstances of each case and the defendant's individual goals and priorities.

About the Author

Kara Hoopis Manosh

Attorney Manosh has dedicated her entire career to defending the rights of the criminally accused. She has handled thousands of cases, appearing in every courthouse in the State of Rhode Island.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Schedule a Consultation

Your rights, your freedom, and your future are at stake. Our dedicated team of career defenders at Manosh Payette, LLC is here to fight for you.

We offer a free case strategy session and will gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation.