The Science of Reasonable Doubt: Forensic Evidence Isn't Always What It Seems
At Manosh Payette Criminal Defense Attorneys, we know that forensic science can make or break a case—and we don't take it at face value.
From crime labs to courtrooms, too many people assume that DNA, fingerprints, or ballistics are ironclad. But real science doesn't work like CSI. We've built our reputation on knowing the difference between junk science and real evidence—and exposing that difference to juries.
We Don't Just Understand Forensic Science—We Fight It
Our attorneys stay at the forefront of developments in forensic standards. We regularly attend national trainings, consult with independent experts, and study the latest updates from organizations like the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the Innocence Project. Our job is to know what's credible—and what's not.
We've successfully cross-examined government experts on:
-
Faulty DNA mixture interpretation – We challenged probabilistic genotyping software (like STRmix) that can produce misleading results from complex samples.
-
Latent fingerprint “matches” – We exposed unreliable fingerprint analysis when examiners claimed certainty without meeting modern scientific validation standards.
-
Gunshot residue tests – We've discredited so-called positive results by showing contamination, improper collection, or lack of scientific rigor.
-
Arson investigations – We've dismantled outdated fire science testimony based on “indicators” that modern science has proven false.
Not Every Expert Is an Expert—And We'll Prove It
We don't just cross-examine forensic experts—we outwork them. Our attorneys have taken advanced forensic training, studied peer-reviewed research, and built a network of consultants who help us dig into the details that others miss.
We've had judges exclude unreliable forensic evidence entirely. We've made prosecutors back off when they realized their science wouldn't hold up. And we've helped juries understand what “reasonable doubt” really looks like—especially when it's wearing a lab coat.
This Is a Trial Firm. We're Not Afraid of Science.
If you or someone you love is facing charges that involve forensic evidence, you need a team that knows how to fight the science. We don't blindly accept lab reports. We break them down, piece by piece. And we do it with one goal: winning your case.
📞 Call us today for a free consultation. 401-854-7794
The lab might say you're guilty. We say: prove it.
